‘Katimbang’ or ‘daripada’? Linguistic adultery that betrays the national language – Mohd Said Bani

What's this obsession with Bahasa Indonesia, asks our contributor

5:22 PM MYT

 

“SAYA suka pisang katimbang epal.”

Wondering what I meant?

It is really concerning to observe the increasing usage of Indonesian dialectal words, such as “katimbang” and “peluncuran,” in contexts where clear and established Bahasa Malaysia terms already exist—namely, “daripada” and “pelancaran.”

This trend not only creates unnecessary confusion among readers and speakers of our national language but also risks eroding the respect and integrity of Bahasa Malaysia as a distinct and cohesive linguistic identity.

The adoption of regional dialects from Indonesia, in official or public usage, dilutes the standardisation of Bahasa Malaysia, leading to ambiguities that hinder effective communication.

For instance, “katimbang” is commonly used in regional Indonesian dialects and is not recognised in standard Bahasa Malaysia.

When such terms are introduced without context or clarification, they disrupt comprehension and force speakers to adapt to vocabulary that lacks familiarity and authenticity within the Malaysian linguistic landscape.

The consequences of integrating foreign dialects into our national language extend beyond mere confusion. 

It signals a weakening commitment to the purity and development of Bahasa Malaysia as a unifying medium for Malaysians.

If left unchecked, this trend could lead to a gradual loss of linguistic identity, as locally established words are overshadowed by regional variations.

The consistent use of clear, standardised terms is crucial for maintaining Bahasa Malaysia’s integrity, especially in formal and educational settings.

In upholding Bahasa Malaysia, it is essential to prioritise widely accepted, standard vocabulary that resonates with all Malaysians.

We must carefully consider the long-term effects of borrowing regional dialects and strive to protect the unique structure and clarity of our language. – November 3, 2024

Prof Mohd Said Bani C. M. Din is a prolific communications practitioner and an advocate for linguistic integrity. He is a firm believer that our language deserves to shine in its purest form.

Topics

 

Popular

MCMC recorded nearly 9,500 reports on cyberbullying in the last three years

Online scams are just behind with 9,321 complaints; 143 reports on child sexual content

Sarawak gas feud in the works? Petros takes Petronas to court over licence dispute

RM7.95 mil clash puts both companies at legal odds over gas supply contract 

Petronas staff to be shown the door to make up losses from Petros deal?

Source claims national O&G firm is expected to see 30% revenue loss once agreed formula for natural gas distribution in Sarawak is implemented

Related